Murfreesboro criminal defense attorney

Weighing the Pros and Cons: Bench Trials vs. Jury Trials in Tennessee

If you have been charged with a criminal offense and you do not wish to enter into a guilty plea agreement with the State, you must eventually navigate the critical decision between opting for a bench trial or a jury trial. Each avenue carries its own set of advantages and disadvantages, influencing the outcome and the process significantly. Understanding these nuances is paramount to choosing which type of trial you wish to occur. While you should always consult with your own criminal defense attorney before making any decision, a Murfreesboro criminal defense lawyer at Bennett | Michael | Hornsby discussing the pros and cons of bench trials vs. juryMurfreesboro criminal defense attorney trials in Tennessee.

Bench Trials

A bench trial is a trial in which a judge, rather than a jury, assesses the evidence, determines credibility, applies the law, and ultimately reaches a verdict. You have a constitutional right to a trial by jury but may waive that right and elect a bench trial instead. Advantages of a bench trial include:

  • Expertise: One primary advantage of bench trials in Tennessee is that your case is decided by a judge who possesses legal expertise and experience. Judges are trained professionals who are well-versed in the law and can apply it impartially to the facts presented.
  • Efficiency: Bench trials are often faster than jury trials. With no jury selection process or deliberations, the proceedings tend to be more streamlined, saving time and resources for all parties involved.
  • Complexity: In cases involving intricate legal matters or technical details, a bench trial might be preferable. Judges are equipped to comprehend and analyze complex legal arguments and evidence, potentially leading to a more informed decision.
  • Consistency: Bench trials offer a level of consistency in decision-making since the outcome relies solely on the interpretation of law by the judge. This consistency can provide a sense of predictability for litigants.

Of course, there are also disadvantages to waiving your right to a jury trial and electing to have a bench trial instead, such as:

  • Subjectivity: Despite their legal expertise, judges are still susceptible to personal biases and interpretations. In a bench trial, the entire verdict rests on the judgment of one individual, which could lead to subjective rulings.
  • Lack of Diversity: Without a jury composed of members of the community, bench trials may lack diverse perspectives and insights that could influence the outcome positively.
  • Public Perception: Some individuals may perceive bench trials as less democratic or transparent compared to jury trials since they lack the participation of peers from the community.

Jury Trials

In Tennessee, a jury trial involved randomly selected community members who serve as jurors. Both the prosecution and defense participate in voir dire to ensure an impartial jury. After all evidence is presented, both sides deliver closing arguments, and the judge then provides instructions on the relevant law, guiding the jury’s deliberations. The jurors then privately discuss the evidence to reach a unanimous verdict. If consensus cannot be reached, a mistrial may occur. There are advantages to exercising your right to a jury trial, including:

  • Community Representation: One of the key advantages of jury trials in Tennessee is the inclusion of community members in the decision-making process. Jurors reflect diverse backgrounds and experiences, potentially offering a broader perspective on the case.
  • Democratic Process: Jury trials embody the democratic principle of having one’s peers decide the outcome. This participatory aspect can enhance the legitimacy of the verdict in the eyes of the public.
  • Checks and Balances: Jury trials act as a check on the power of the judiciary. They provide a safeguard against judicial overreach or bias by allowing the community to directly influence the verdict.
  • Emotional Appeal: In cases where emotional appeal plays a significant role, jurors may be more receptive to human elements of the case, leading to outcomes driven by empathy and compassion.

Just like bench trials, jury trials have disadvantages as well as advantages. Some important disadvantages to electing a jury trial include:

  • Complexity and Education: Jurors may lack the legal knowledge and understanding necessary to grasp complex legal issues fully. This could result in misinterpretation of evidence or confusion during deliberations.
  • Time and Resources: Jury trials are typically lengthier and more resource-intensive than bench trials. The process of jury selection, deliberations, and coordination adds considerable time and cost to the proceedings.
  • Influence of Prejudice: Despite efforts to ensure impartiality, jurors may be influenced by personal biases, prejudices, or external factors, potentially leading to unjust verdicts.

Ultimately, understanding the advantages and disadvantages of both bench and jury trials and discussing those advantages and disadvantages with an experienced criminal defense attorney is essential in making an informed decision that aligns with your legal objectives and preferences.

Contact a Murfreesboro Defense Attorney 

If you are facing criminal charges in Tennessee, consult with an experienced Murfreesboro criminal defense attorney at Bennett | Michael | Hornsby as soon as possible to ensure that your rights are protected. Contact the team today by calling 615-898-1560 to schedule your free appointment.


Stan Bennett